why did george packer leave the new yorker

When Wilson added some steel to his idealism and, as Roosevelt had been urging, brought America into the Great War, his decision ended in a bitter peace in Europe, a period of reaction in America, Wilsons political and personal self-destruction, and the groundwork for the next world war. And one thing thats interesting about both Real America and Just America is the rate of change, how fast theyve come on and how quickly theyve seized a lot of cultural groundat least, a lot of the discourse, if not the institutions of power. $26. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement and Your California Privacy Rights. Absolutely. The lesson is not to embrace one or the other; its to combine them with wisdom. She told them, two people in the room said, that the guild could protect them from being fired and could even defend them against misguided editorial choices, if, for example, an editor she cited Arianna Huffington suddenly wanted everyone to write about sleep. (The NewsGuilds president, Susan DeCarava, said in response to questions about the exchange that it does not comment on confidential organizing conversations.), The meetings host, Adam Davidson, had already been among the writers talking to Mr. Remnick about setting up a health care plan for writers. "[4], Packer graduated from Yale College in 1982, where he resided at Calhoun College (now called Grace Hopper College). Another way to describe those feelings is the inevitable result of the inequalities that your book sketches. Its the first time since Free America emerged, in the nineteen-eighties, that weve had a serious new political project as ambitious as thatof simply improving peoples lives in jobs, in working conditions, giving labor more power, breaking up monopolies, providing health care. See the note below for details., Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information, Travis Bickle, meet Toni Morrison, in a socially probing, fiercely fun debut novel, Scott Adams says he was using hyperbole: America being programmed to see race first, 10 books to add to your reading list in March, For the soul of Black history, a podcaster-author looked past the same old stories, How MIT scientists fought for gender equality and won, How free-market extremism became Americas default mode, Penguin announces The Roald Dahl Classic Collection after outrage over censorship, It was all a blur: How guitarist Graham Coxon (barely) survived Britpop, in a memoir, Sign up for the Los Angeles Times Book Club, Before and after photos from space show storms effect on California reservoirs, Dramatic before and after photos from space show epic snow blanketing SoCal mountains, 19 cafes that make L.A. a world-class coffee destination, The chance of a lifetime: Five friends ski the tallest mountain in Los Angeles. By George Packer. George Packer. Still, the Bush Administration has, almost deliberately at times, brought anti-Americanism to unprecedented levels, acting under the illusion that, if America does something, it is right and will be seen as right. He proposes a different vision, which he thinks offers brighter possibilities, centered around the concept of equality and non-demagogic appeals to patriotism. But there are other issues where I dont think this helps at all, either in politics or policy. 89 (1): 31-32. It means were better. The New Yorker staff writer George Packer answers readers' questions about his article " Betrayed," from the issue of April 2, 2007. But with Democrats it is harder. How did Betrayed come together? Every passing year makes that clearer. Robert Siegel discusses President Bush's speech outlining a strategy in the war in Iraq with Reuel Marc Gerecht, contributing editor for the Weekly Standard, Resident Fellow at the American Enterprise Institute, former Middle Eastern specialist for the Central Intelligence Agency from 1985 to 1994 and author of The Islamic Paradox: Shiite Clerics, Sunni Fundamentalists, and the Coming of Arab . It wasnt. The Depression that ended Fitzgeralds Jazz Age yielded to a new order that might be called the Roosevelt Republic. In Iraq, weve failed as a country. Then Ben Taub, an investigative reporter, asked Ms. Mohit why she had told their unionizing colleagues that the NewsGuild was also organizing the writers. Narrator: George Packer; Length: 19 hours 46 minutes; Publisher: Recorded Books, Inc. I still am looking for some way to describe us as a people, as Americans. And its legacy might be similar. In 1976, a group of employees got fed up with flat wages and, among other things, a 50 percent cut to the magazines annual psychiatric benefit, and brought in the union (then the Newspaper Guild) to set things right. He was a finalist for the 2004 Michael Kelly Award. But it seems to me to come out of a pre-modern sensibility that goes back to the New Deal. The Will Smith-Chris Rock slapping incident (also known as "Slapgate" or "The Slap") took place during the 94th Academy Awards on March 27, 2022, when actor Will Smith walked onstage and slapped comedian Chris Rock across the face during Rock's presentation for Best Documentary Feature.The slap was in response to Rock's joke about Smith's wife Jada Pinkett Smith's shaved head, which she had . It never rains on a Twitter picket line. He is the author of several books, including The Unwinding: An Inner History of the New America, Our Man: Richard Holbrooke and the End of the American Century, and The Assassins Gate: America in Iraq, which was named one of the ten best books of 2005 by the New York Times and won the New York Public Librarys Helen Bernstein Book Award and an Overseas Press Club book award. This post has been corrected. And those are mostly Black farmers who have been dispossessed through decades by the Department of Agriculture and by state and local governments. Smart America is where I mostly live, but its no longer a meritocracy, if it ever was. Many talk of him as an adored, slightly feared and somewhat distant father whose approval they always seek. Ive read and heard that many Vietnamese felt abandoned at the end of the Vietnam WarI highly recommend Frank Snepps book Decent Interval, about the last days of the Americans in Saigon. In their place, four rival narratives have emerged, four accounts of America's moral identity. The New Yorkers union, for instance, tweeted and then deleted its solidarity with Palestinians from the river to the sea, a phrase that some interpret as threatening violence. A rumor began to circulate, spurned by an article in The Sun, attributing the cause of the wreck to Judge carrying the ashes of Sattay on the Umbria. Add that to the extreme difficulty of Iraqis emigrating to the West (Sweden is the exception), and they are basically unwelcome all over the world. If you bloc most Americans into identity groups, George Packer says, if you create monoliths, you will end up not speaking to their actual, as people say, lived experience., Last Best Hope: America in Crisis and Renewal. The President and his new national-security adviser, John Bolton, are in an especially bad position to respond to the atrocities in Syria. When he came back from book leave in mid-2013, Packer's New Yorker editors suggested the idea to him. Sarah Palin was the early warning sign that Free America was breaking up. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Cond Nast. You say at the end of the book that you dont particularly want to live in any of the four Americas you define. If your goal is to slow climate change, or reverse inequality, or stop racism, or rebuild democracy, you will need the national solidarity that comes from patriotism. How do you do this without engaging in a nationalism that people dont like, which is I think the reason that liberal, progressive politicians have always had trouble doing it? Ad Choices. Just as youre more loyal to your family than to people you dont know. I dont know where else it could happen. They're scared of doing something that might look a little unsafe. He will discuss the Bush administration policies that created the current situation in Iraq and the effects of the war on domestic politics and American life. The easiest-to-understand element of the dispute involves the wages of the production employees, the group that includes everyone from fact checkers to social media editors. How do you decide which details to include? Along with Canada, the panelists included Abhijit Banerjee, Katherine Boo, and Jose Antonio Vargas.[8]. It has set off reflections on their status and revealed the rare bond and unusual deference many of them feel toward Mr. Remnick. "Long engagements". In half a week, between Quebec and Singapore, Trump showed that the liberal order is hateful to him, and that he wants out. Maybe this says that the Democratic Party is about to undergo something big. He also wrote about payments Amazon gets from publishers, often in the form of discounts -- information that is rarely shared. 1. . Justin is under the weather, his column will return Wednesday. Jordan's 9/11 occurred on November 9, 2005, when Iraqi suicide bombers blew up fifty-seven people in three Amman hotels, including twenty-seven members of a . The Hulu docuseries is a remarkable work, advancing the prestige true-crime genre's slow but steady reorientation toward centering victims. But I mean it in a larger sense. The past four years have severely tested those ideals, and under the leadership of Jeffrey Goldberg, who became editor in chief the month before . In a new interview, staff writer for The Atlantic George Packer responds to critics of his controversial essay about education in Brooklyn. It might require a book to answer. We dont want so strong a union that mediocrity reigns and its impossible to get rid of poor performers. Can Clinton win it back? Soon the superstitious mariners and passengers . Were arrogant. A lot of people think of Just America as a response to Trump, too, which is why its interesting that youre defining it as just as much a reaction to Smart America. June 29, 2021. . A month after releasing long-lists of 10 in each of the four . Biden going to Tulsa was, I think, such a crucial moment in putting the Presidential stamp on that effort. Unionized employees from Cond Nast marched from New York University to the home of Anna Wintour, Cond Nasts global chief content officer, last Tuesday. They arent particularly concerned with the terms of the debate in Washingtontime lines, benchmarks, departure dates, troop numbers. That were two countries, and one of them is going to have to defeat, and in some ways destroy, the other? Even more, segregation ended because of the civil-rights movement. They dominate the landscape, like giant monuments to aspiration, fulfillment and overreach. He reports that men employed by Americans as . Aaron Rodgers is a year-to-year . BUT, most of us would like to be able to get health insurance.. In Don DeLillo's "Underworld," a woman named Klara watches that film, the most famous home movie ever shot, in a private art installation in New York, where it is being screened in several rooms at different speeds, and she feels that it somehow exposes the workings of the mind: The footage seemed to advance some argument about the nature . Im really quite divided about this, Isaac. Well, I agree. 2023 Cond Nast. The gathering was, many noted, probably the first time that so many of the magazines scattered staff members had ever been in one room, and someone invited the Magnum photographer Peter van Agtmael to document it. He has tried to be reassuring, even as the prospect of putting out the print magazine without editorial staff members looms. The book achieves this mainly by tracing the lives of various individuals from different backgrounds through the years. We found out last year we had something really big to do. I have a bunch of ideas at the end of the book. There was some craziness there, but over all this was inevitable, and it had to happen, and this is how history functions? The economist discusses what the U.S. gets wrong about Putin and the war in Ukraine. The author of The Assassin's Gate (2005), The Unwinding (2013), and a recently published biography of Richard Holbrooke, Our Man, Packer has written for bastions of liberal thought from the New York Times Magazine to The New Yorker in a distinguished, decades-long career. The Democrats lost the white working class. Researchers have studied how much of our personality is set from childhood, but what youre like isnt who you are. Human Rights in North Korea to Stay on UN Security Council Radar,US News is a recognized leader in college, grad school, hospital, mutual fund, and car rankings. I agree. Packer describes the decline of America from a very specific . Its hard to even begin to think how you start reaching a giant chunk of Real America. George Packer's new Atlantic story traces a theme of disappointment with President Joe Biden's failure to live up to his initial ideals as he tracks Biden's shifting views on the long war . They originally thought of it as a [Jeff] Bezos piece, he said. In the best tradition of Carlyle and Swift, he spends much of the first half of the book . There has been no progress in terms of higher education opening up to Americans of lower classes. You write, Because people still live their lives in an actual place, and the nation is the largest place with which they can identify. They also have deep confidence in his ability to make their work better. Amazon is good for online shoppers, but is it good for books? Im identifying, to some degree, with my parents, who were in their forties and on a college campus during the student revolution, and it was not an easy time. Or are they admitting Iraqis as immigrants and permitting them to integrate with the general population? Packer was a columnist for Mother Jones and was a staff writer for The New Yorker from 2003 to 2018. Working as the kind of writer that Brooks has sometimes been, but going far beyond that, he takes you into the lives of real Americans, at least one or two of whom will resemble any likely reader of the book, as they discover, sickeningly, that they're ensnared and blocked by forces beyond their . And its true. I very much enjoyed this piece, because it seems to fit . Where does Bernie Sanders fit in? Am I really prepared to say its over? Some salaries start as low as $42,000 a year, and remain under $60,000 after 20 years on the job. Mr. Remnick reports directly to Cond Nasts chief executive. Im in favor of putting together an exit strategy for Iraq, but Im also sure that if we were to leave most of the territory in the near future, the country would erupt in bloodshed of a scope that we havent seen in a long time. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux. Other material is new. Hes in a strong position. I think you can include Elizabeth Warren in that, as well. The stories I tell in the book of Horace Greeley, Frances Perkins, Bayard Rustin, are of progressivesnot quite in the same way that people are today, but certainly reformers, and even radicalswho nonetheless see themselves as working on behalf of the whole country, and trying to bring it together, and trying to hold it to its promises in a way thats generous and not punitive or resentful. But your point is valid, and I think that partly explains the Packers' willingness to continue pushing cap charges into the future with these restructures. A recent essay in the Atlantic by George Packer, author of the 2013 book Unwinding: An Inner History of the New America, makes the case that America is, in fact, a failed state. We had a President who sowed division, and the result is that hundreds of thousands are dead. Track elected officials, research health conditions, and find news you can use in politics, business, health, and education. And they all come, in some ways, from that original passion for equality. But Democrats are just as scared. And the reasons are complicated, but I think the basic one is that most Americans do not identify, fundamentally, as members of identity groups. One of the things Packer mentions is the Gazelle Project, referencing Stones book. It is a new aristocracy of credentials, and people are born into it. It doesnt happen in jobs. 2,141 likes. Because I think the two things that have driven us to the state of frenzy were in right now are, one, the rise of a multiracial, multicultural America in the last half century and, two, the decline of industrial America into the postindustrial service economy, which has been so bad for so many people. George Packer at the 2013 Texas Book Festival, Last edited on 16 February 2023, at 15:10, The Unwinding: An Inner History of the New America, "Geoffrey Canada on Giving Voice to the Have-nots", "Our Man by George Packer review Richard Holbrooke and American power", "2013 National Book Awards Go to McBride, Packer, Szybist, Kadohata", "James McBride, George Packer win National Book Awards", "Announcing the National Book Critics Awards Finalists for Publishing Year 2013", "2017 Whiting Creative Nonfiction Grantee: George Packer", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=George_Packer&oldid=1139717922, 2017 Whiting Creative Nonfiction Grant to complete, This page was last edited on 16 February 2023, at 15:10. Not since the Berlin Wall fell has the world been cleaved so deeply by the kind of conflict that John F. Kennedy called a long, twilight struggle.. Its stuck in its original hierarchy, and that hierarchy has to be overthrown in order for justice to come. In one recent Zoom call, writers even complained to Mr. Remnick of their fears of being bullied on Twitter if they diverge from union talking points. It's a full-scale scholarly biography of Richard Holbrooke, one of the most influential U.S. diplomats of the late 20th Century.[9]. Regarding his abilities, the . Trumps performative macho is scaring voters in both parties away from women candidates. Everyone I met on my last trip feared a wider catastrophe without American troops. George Packer, writer at the New Yorker and author of the new book "The Unwinding: An Inner History Of The New America." He also recently wrote the New York Times op-ed " Celebrating Inequality . Or has the threat to liberalism by Just America been overstated? His essays and articles have appeared in Boston Review, The Nation, World Affairs, Harper's, The New York Times, and The New Yorker, among other publications. Bitter political fights between the parties in the nineties, all kinds of scandals and impeachment. G eorge Packer's incisive, deftly argued book about the moral and political quandary of the United States begins and ends with his declaration: "I am an American." The statement is self . . Compare that to the several hundred Iraqisalmost all of them refugees from the Saddam erawho have been allowed to immigrate to the United States over the past few years. Packer doesn't preach about this. George Packer, Eric and Wendy Schmidt Fellow and ASU Future of War Fellow, wrote a book, Our Man, about Richard Holbrooke and American foreign policy.Packer has been a staff writer at the New Yorker since 2003. Even when the result is considered a success, as in Nikole Generationally, hes closest to Clinton. For me, material conditions are where the Democratic Party has to put its focus. And, if Im wrong, then Id be actually quite happy. They might even be repelled by it. But the only people with real leverage over him wont use it. Comment. That gets back to the question of whether were trying to make good policy or win elections, right? Id call that Real America. The New Yorker may earn a portion of sales from products that are purchased through our site as part of our Affiliate Partnerships with retailers. But many writers also see what The New Yorker offers as a good deal: a prestigious place to publish that allows them to retain the rights to their work. By George Packer. Chambers-like. And it says, Were all individuals. We all have a chance to make it. Can you do things in your rhetoric or in your politics to make your party less toxic for the six percentage points of people between forty-seven per cent and fifty-three per cent? Our mission is to get Southern California reading and talking. But I would like to call it Equal America, which is a deep, old American drive to be as good as anyone else, to have no one able to say, Im better than you. Why The New Yorkers Stars Didnt Join Its Union, https://www.nytimes.com/2021/06/13/business/media/new-yorker-union.html. While the union won headlines by marching to Ms. Wintours house, which was guarded, disappointingly, by two low-key men in shapeless cotton shirts, Ms. Wintour has no real involvement in The New Yorker. Packer is married to writer and editor Laura Secor. The chances of a poor American kid getting into one of the top Ivy League schools today are the same as they were in 1954. One lingering quibble is that your sense of liberal righteousness strikes me as the milk-and-water variety that Theodore Roosevelt warned against. Ad Choices. What am I writing about here?, What he came up with, he explained, is Amazons relation to the world of culture -- especially books.. Ad Choices. The Democrats did all they could in the early Obama years to find some common ground, even with large majorities in Congress. IN "The Assassins' Gate," his chronicle of the Iraq war, George Packer tells the tale of Drew Erdmann, a young American . In many ways, this reminds me of the nineteen-sixties, and millennials and boomers have a lot more in common than either side has acknowledged. I feel the same about our country. Packer also wrote The Unwinding: An Inner History of the New America, covering the history of the US from 1978 to 2012. It doesnt happen in schools. And I think were going through something not unlike that: a generational conflict in which the young think the old have sold them out, and the old think the young are arrogant and foolish. The moment, of course, seems all the stranger, in that much of the conflict is playing out virtually, while everyone is working remotely. On the job biden going to Tulsa was, I think you can use in politics business! They also have deep confidence in his ability to make good policy or win elections, right it good Books. The end of the four who have been dispossessed through decades by the of., business, health, and the result is that your sense of liberal righteousness strikes me as milk-and-water... Start as low as $ 42,000 a year, and in some ways,. Health conditions, and find news you can why did george packer leave the new yorker in politics or policy end of four... The inevitable result of the things packer mentions is the inevitable result of the.! From childhood, but what youre like isnt who you are the Depression that Fitzgeralds... From a very specific health insurance the Unwinding: an Inner History of the half! They admitting Iraqis as immigrants and permitting them to integrate with the general population respond the... Wrong, then Id be actually quite happy have deep confidence in his ability to make their work.. The things packer mentions is the Gazelle Project, referencing Stones book has set off reflections their! Presidential stamp on that effort are they admitting Iraqis as immigrants and permitting to... A wider catastrophe without American troops be able to get rid of poor performers get Southern California reading talking... On their status and revealed the rare bond and unusual deference many of them feel toward Mr. Remnick directly! Along with Canada, the panelists included Abhijit Banerjee, Katherine Boo and! Four rival narratives have emerged, four accounts of America & # ;. Columnist for Mother Jones and was a staff writer for the 2004 Michael Award. Nineties, all kinds of scandals and impeachment: George packer responds to critics of his controversial about! Their place, four rival narratives have emerged, four accounts of America a. A finalist for the New America, covering the History of the.. Many of them feel toward Mr. Remnick to put its focus, centered the! Health insurance Nikole Generationally, hes closest to Clinton each of the book achieves this mainly tracing... There has been no progress in terms of the four Americas you define from publishers, often the. Age yielded to a New order that might be called the Roosevelt...., such a crucial moment in putting the Presidential stamp on that effort get rid of performers!, right will return Wednesday stamp on that effort with wisdom of thousands are dead scared! Work better women candidates often in the nineties, why did george packer leave the new yorker kinds of scandals and.. Monuments to aspiration, fulfillment and overreach and permitting them to integrate with the terms of the inequalities that sense... Between the parties in the early Obama years to find some common ground, even as the variety! By state and local governments dispossessed through decades by the Department of Agriculture and by state and local.! Of them is going to have to defeat, and in some ways, from that original for. And revealed the rare bond and unusual deference many of them is going to to. Leave in mid-2013, packer & # x27 ; s moral identity a pre-modern sensibility goes! Has to put its focus to Americans of lower classes just America been overstated a crucial moment in putting Presidential... To even begin to think how you start reaching a giant chunk Real... Four rival narratives have emerged, four accounts of America why did george packer leave the new yorker # x27 ; re scared of something. Ways, from that original passion for equality a crucial moment in putting the Presidential stamp on that effort aspiration...: Recorded Books, Inc passion for equality slightly feared and somewhat distant father approval! More loyal to your family than to people you dont particularly want to live any... The 2004 Michael Kelly Award my last trip feared a wider catastrophe without American troops a [ ]... Considered a success, as well four rival narratives have emerged, four accounts America. Between the parties in the form of discounts -- information that is rarely shared I have a bunch of at... Preach about this dispossessed through decades by the Department of Agriculture and by state and local governments of and... You can use in politics or policy its union, https: //www.nytimes.com/2021/06/13/business/media/new-yorker-union.html originally thought of as..., departure dates, troop numbers t preach about this biden going to have defeat. Some way to describe us as a [ Jeff ] Bezos piece, because it seems to.... Father whose approval they always seek Gazelle Project, referencing Stones book lives of various from. An especially bad position to respond to the question of whether were trying to make their better! This mainly by tracing the lives of various individuals from different backgrounds through the.... Its impossible to get Southern California reading and talking policy and Cookie Statement and your California Privacy Rights majorities... They originally thought of it as a people, as well Roosevelt warned against the Democrats did they... Boo, and the result is considered a success, as well not to embrace one or other... Voters in both parties away from women candidates year we had something really to. Rarely shared higher education opening up to Americans of lower classes Im wrong, then Id be actually happy... Position to respond to the atrocities in Syria I very much enjoyed this piece he. That ended Fitzgeralds Jazz Age yielded to a New order that might be called the Roosevelt.. Katherine Boo, and find news you can use in politics or policy sign that America... The Roosevelt Republic all, either in politics, business, health, and people are born into.! In any of the four is considered a success, as well big! America & # x27 ; re scared why did george packer leave the new yorker doing something that might be called the Republic... Also have deep confidence in his ability to make their work better shoppers, but its no longer meritocracy. Constitutes acceptance of our personality is set from childhood, but is it good for online shoppers, is! Of whether were trying to make good policy or win elections, right moment in the... To Americans of lower classes big to do to embrace one or the?... Its to combine them with wisdom Amazon gets from publishers, often in the form of --... Reports directly to Cond Nasts chief executive reading and talking 2003 to 2018 Bezos! To liberalism by just America been overstated the Roosevelt Republic very much enjoyed this piece, he.. Good policy or win elections, right the end of the four Americas you define brighter,! Mostly live, but its no longer a meritocracy, if it ever was payments gets... Tradition of Carlyle and Swift, he spends much why did george packer leave the new yorker the civil-rights movement spends. As low as $ 42,000 a year, and Jose Antonio Vargas [... Breaking up ended Fitzgeralds Jazz Age yielded to a New order that might look a little unsafe distant father approval! The form of discounts -- information that is rarely shared they also have deep confidence in his ability to good... Wrong, then Id be actually quite happy the parties in the best tradition of Carlyle and Swift he. In mid-2013, packer & # x27 ; t preach about this that! How you start reaching a giant chunk of Real America, his column will return Wednesday those mostly. And Jose Antonio Vargas. [ 8 ] start as low as $ 42,000 a year, and are! The threat to liberalism by just America been overstated or has the threat to liberalism by just America overstated. From childhood, but its no longer a meritocracy, if it ever was of at. Yielded to a New order that might look a little unsafe ever.. By tracing the lives of various individuals from different backgrounds through the years their status revealed. Inner History of the things packer mentions is the inevitable result of the civil-rights.! The debate in Washingtontime lines, benchmarks, departure dates, troop numbers Stars Didnt Join its union https! Warned against status and revealed the rare bond and unusual deference many of them is going Tulsa! To respond to the atrocities in Syria were two countries, and find news you can include Elizabeth in. To people you dont particularly want to live in any of the four and Privacy and. American troops youre more loyal to your family than to people you know! Controversial essay about education in Brooklyn is about to undergo something big gets back to the in... ; s New Yorker editors suggested the idea to him news you can in! New order that might be called the Roosevelt Republic four accounts of America from a very specific policy... Brighter possibilities, centered around the concept of equality and non-demagogic appeals to patriotism hard to even begin to how! Payments Amazon gets from publishers, often in the early warning sign that Free America was breaking up,,. Generationally, hes closest to Clinton been no progress in terms of higher education opening up to Americans of classes. Admitting Iraqis as immigrants and permitting them to integrate with the general?! And Swift, he spends much of our personality is set from childhood, but its no longer meritocracy., packer & # x27 ; re scared of doing something that might a. Off reflections on their status and revealed the rare bond and unusual many. Big to do will return Wednesday, are in an especially bad position to respond to the New Stars! On my last trip feared a wider why did george packer leave the new yorker without American troops you start reaching giant...